Tag Archives: first test

The Ashes: First test compendium

July 15, 2013 By in Shumpty Speaks Tags: , , , , , , Leave a comment

Well the first test is over and here is a compendium of all of my posts relating to it:

The English team named: https://shumpty77.com/2013/07/07/the-ashes-england-squad-announcement/

The Australian team named: https://shumpty77.com/2013/07/10/the-ashes-australian-team-named/

Reflections on day 1: https://shumpty77.com/2013/07/11/the-ashes-1st-test-day-one-some-reflections/

Reflections on day 2: https://shumpty77.com/2013/07/12/the-ashes-day-2-reflections/

Considering the drama from day 3 and the issue of Stuart Broad’s conduct: https://shumpty77.com/2013/07/13/the-ashes-on-the-question-of-broad-and-walking/

Reflections on day 4: https://shumpty77.com/2013/07/14/the-ashes-first-test-day-4-reflections/

The final day equation: https://shumpty77.com/2013/07/14/the-ashes-first-test-the-last-day-equation/

The five lessons from the result of the 1st Test: https://shumpty77.com/2013/07/15/the-ashes-first-test-the-5-lessons/

The first test player report card: https://shumpty77.com/2013/07/15/the-ashes-1st-test-player-report-card/

It was just a brilliant game of test match cricket that ebbed and flowed throughout. With only 3 days to go till the second test at Lords I can hope that it is half as good as the game just gone.

The Ashes: 1st Test Player Report Card

July 15, 2013 By in Shumpty Speaks Tags: , , , , 1 Comment

After such a brilliant first test match and with the second test match only three days away, it is time to run the ruler over the performances of each player from both teams.

Australia

Shane Watson: 7 out of 10

Dismissed sparring at a leavable ball outside the off stump in the first innings and LBW in his usual style in the second after getting off to a good start. Was a miser with the ball but did not bowl enough to slot into the allrounders roll Australia needs.

Chris Rogers: 7 out of 10

Did the job he was asked to do and showed glimpses in both innings of why he has been tapped on the shoulder for this series.

Ed Cowan: 2 out of 10

Two bad shots and his career is in jeopardy. To be honest they were shots that were indicative of a clouded mind. Will play at Lords but will be on his last chance.

Michael Clarke: 5 out of 10

Got a jaffa from Anderson in the first innings and then wafted at one outside off stump in the second. Never looked set and Australia needs his production to succeed here. Appalling on reviews to DRS.

Steve Smith: 7 out of 10

A solid knock in the first innings was followed by a good ball from Swann in the second innings. Needed to make more his opportunity in the first innings and went hard at a ball that he should have left.

Phil Hughes: 7.5 out of 10

Kept it together in the first innings and had pundits calling him Steve Waugh reincarnate. Maybe number 6 is his position but he looked all at see against Graeme Swann in the second innings and was found out.

Brad Haddin: 7.5 out of 10

A fantastic knock in the second innings probably will do much to mask some frailties with his glove work that have been much made of until his last day stand. Is the old head Australia needs in the middle order but must assert himself more on the field in DRS scenarios.

Peter Siddle: 7 out of 10

8 wickets in the test match was a solid return to form for Siddle. Lionhearted in the second innings and, despite his limitations, continued to lead the attack wholeheartedly when others were starting to wilt.

Mitchell Starc: 6 out of 10

Wayward when we needed him to be on line but is a top order wicket taker and did so in the first innings albeit with a bit of luck. Will need to work on his control for the second test.

James Pattinson: 6.5 out of 10

Read the comments on Starc. Same rules apply to Pattinson. Last wicket heroics with Haddin get him the extra half a point.

Ashton Agar: 8 out of 10

The statement that this was the best Ashes debut ever is hyperbole: Bob Massie wins that battle by the length of the straight. Still though this was an excellent start for the young man.

England

Alistair Cook: 7 out of 10

Solid with the bat without being outstanding and marshalled his troops well when things were going pear shaped on day 5. Was excellent on his use of DRS.

Joe Root: 4 out of 10

Looked a little out his depth at the top of the order albeit scratched out 30 in the first innings. Looks a long term prospect for England if they don’t bugger him up.

Jonathan Trott: 5 out of 10

Looked like he was serenely going on his way to another hundred in the first innings until he played a shocking shot off Siddle (he was not the only one) and got a bad decision in the second innings for a golden duck. Will play a major part in this series at some point.

Kevin Pietersen: 7 out of 10

Is there a better player of the straight drive in the game of cricket? Love him or hate him Pietersen’s second innings 64 was an important precursor to the Bell / Broad partnership that changed the game.

Ian Bell: 9 out of 10

A career defining hundred in the second innings. It was a brilliant innings without which England would not have won the game.

Jonny Bairstow: 6.5 out of 10

Is another player of the future and will be better for this test match. His first innings 37 was vital batting with the tail to get England over 200.

Matt Prior: 5 out of 10

Out to two woeful shots but showed wonderful intent in the second innings when he went hard at the second new ball and got England on top. His glove work was exemplary and his work advising Cook on DRS decisions just as good!

Stuart Broad: 7.5 out of 10

Forget the sore shoulder and the controversy of not walking: this was a solid all round performance from a much maligned player. A quick fire 24 in the first innings when things were going haywire and a staunch 64 in concert with Bell in the second inning in the match winning partnership from number 8 where match winners. 2 key wickets in each innings show his value in this England team.

Graeme Swann: 7 out of 10

A dear in the headlights with the willow but tied up one end for the English while Jimmy Anderson worked his magic. Big wickets at the end of day 4 turned the match the way of the Poms.

Steve Finn: 3 out of 10

Over 5 runs an over in the first innings and then targeted by Brad Haddin the second. Was just too inconsistent with length and line and was the obvious weak link in the English attack. Will struggle to keep his position for the next test.

Jimmy Anderson: 10 out of 10

Just a brilliant performance from one of the best bowlers in the world. He was a class above any other bowler in this game. His 13 over spell to start day 5 was the match winner. A worthy man of the match.

The Ashes: First Test … the 5 lessons

July 15, 2013 By in Shumpty Speaks Tags: , , , Leave a comment

What an amazing first test match of this winter’s Ashes series. That is what test cricket is all about: it is hard fought, it is tense and it is close.

Simply put: the best team won and that was England. Australia fought hard and will take many positives from the game.

Here are my five lessons from the first test:

James Anderson: Superstar

If you ever needed convincing, and I for one did, Anderson’s 13 over spell to start day 5 was just a brilliant effort and showed that he was in a class above the other bowlers in this test match. 10 wickets, the bowlers century, on that wicket was nothing short of exceptional.

DRS: that is the system … live with it

It was inevitable wasn’t it that the DRS would play a role in the end of the game? I have to confess that in real time my first instinct was the Brad Haddin had touched the ball on the way to Matt Prior and I have no cavil with how Umpire Erasmus went about his decision there. The fact is though there are massive flaws in the system. The second fact, which is more important, is that the system is here to stay and can not be changed mid-series. We are going to have to get used to seeing a scintilla of the ball hitting the stumps being deemed “umpires call” and get on with it!

Brad Haddin: Streetfighter

I can not be more complimentary about the innings of Brad Haddin. It was an gritty and hard fought knock that was perfectly paced in almost stole the game. That innings is a snapshot of exactly why Haddin was picked for this series. Strong in mind and strong in will Haddin was perfect in the role of Australia’s almost savour.

Number 11s made Australia look better than we were

Let’s be honest here: Australia was very lucky to be in the position is was in going into the second innings of this match. Additionally, we are lucky we are not sitting here lamenting an 80 run loss rather than a 14 run one. 123 runs out of our number 11 batsman was unexpected and indeed welcome. That said, the success of our lower order has been masking the failures of the top six for some time now and again Australia has finished a test match without a test century from any player. I know finding form takes time BUT everyone in our top six needs to find some and fast! Obviously there are some players more under the microscope than others but this is a whole of order problem.

Test cricket: how good is it?

18,000 fans in the ground at Nottingham and millions around the world witnessed a fantastic first test match in a battle between two proud countries that is now in its 126th year. Obviously, not all test matches are going to be like this but, if nothing else, this test match should have tattooed in the minds of those who believe test matches are a dying form of the game that it is well and truly alive and kicking.

We now have a 3 day break before the second test at the Home of Cricket, Lords. Time to bank some sleep and get ready for round two of this ten round super heavyweight bought.